The Aftersell alternative for the whole store
Rebuy vs Aftersell: More revenue. Fewer apps.
Rebuy gives growing and enterprise Shopify brands one platform to lift conversion, AOV and lifetime value across the whole store, without stitching together separate apps or waiting on a developer.
What is the difference between Rebuy and Aftersell?
The main difference between Rebuy and Aftersell is that Rebuy is best suited for Shopify brands that want one AI engine personalizing the whole store, from the homepage, search and bundles to cart, checkout and post-purchase, while Aftersell is best suited for brands focused mainly on upsells in the cart, at checkout and after purchase.
Updated November 2026. Based on each company's public product pages and help docs.
-
$3.8B+
in new revenue for merchants
-
50,000+
Shopify brands
-
40+
app integrations
Why Rebuy
Why Shopify brands choose Rebuy over Aftersell
-
Whole-store personalization
Personalize the whole store, not just the order
Rebuy puts AI recommendations on your homepage, product and collection pages, and adds Smart Search, Smart Collections and bundles. Aftersell's products cover product page upsells, the cart, checkout, post-purchase and the thank-you page.
-
Rebuy AI
One shopper profile behind every offer
Rebuy AI learns from billions of data points and powers search, product pages, cart, checkout and post-purchase from one shopper profile. Aftersell uses machine learning in its cart and Shopify's own recommender at checkout.
-
Rebuy Monetize
Free revenue from your thank-you page
Rebuy Monetize is free and needs no other Rebuy package. It runs on the thank-you and order status pages in the US, Canada and the UK, with offers from brands like Prime Video, HelloFresh and Disney. Offers vary by location.
-
Integrations and developers
Works with your stack and your developers
Smart Cart connects with 40+ apps, including Klaviyo, Attentive, Recharge, Yotpo and Okendo. Rebuy also offers APIs, custom templates and JavaScript events; Aftersell's help docs say it has no general developer API.
Rebuy vs Aftersell: full feature comparison
See every place Rebuy adds revenue, from the homepage to the thank-you page, and the apps it can replace.
| Feature | Rebuy | Aftersell |
|---|---|---|
| Where it personalizes | ✓Entire customer journey: homepage, product and collection pages, site search, cart, checkout, post-purchase, thank-you and order status pages, customer accounts, reorder pages and emails | ⊖Limited: Product pages, cart, checkout, post-purchase, thank-you page |
| Recommendation AI | ✓Rebuy AI engine for every product, trained on billions of data points | ⊖Limited: Separate engines for cart, checkout and post-purchase |
| Site search and collection pages | ✓Smart Search (AI results in under 0.2 seconds) and Smart Collections | ✕Not part of Aftersell's product lineup |
| Bundles | ✓Dynamic Bundles (AI-powered and flexible rules, one-click add to cart) and Bundle Builder (shoppers build their own bundle) | ⊖Limited: Manually selected product page bundles, and a bundle option after purchase. Build a Box runs as a post-purchase offer |
| Customer journeys and promotions | ✓Smart Flows | ✕Not documented by Aftersell |
| A/B testing | ✓Unlimited, schedulable tests on recommendations, merchandising, search, content, cart and post-purchase | ⊖Limited: Cart, checkout and post-purchase |
| Thank-you page ads | ✓Rebuy Monetize | ✓Rokt Thanks |
| App integrations | ✓40+ | ⊖Limited: ~14About 14, listed in Aftersell's help docs |
| Developer API | ✓Yes, including a headless search API | ✕No general developer API, per its help docs |
Information based on each company's publicly available documentation, 2026. Subject to change.
Compare Rebuy and Aftersell product by product
-
Both offer a no-code slide-out cart with rewards, gifts, subscriptions and express checkout. Rebuy's Smart Cart adds Rebuy AI, quantity-tier discounts, scheduled carts, a two-column layout and 40+ integrations.
Feature Rebuy Smart Cart Aftersell Cart Slide-out cart for any Shopify theme ✓Yes ✓Yes No-code editor ✓Yes, drag-and-drop ✓Yes, click-to-edit and drag-and-drop AI product recommendations ✓Yes, Rebuy AI using cart, browsing and purchase history ✓Yes, machine learning or hand-picked Personalize by shopper ✓Yes, AI plus purchase history, geolocation and traffic intent ✓Yes, rules on cart contents, tags, subtotal and shipping country Tiered progress bar ✓Yes, for free shipping, discounts and gifts ✓Yes, for free shipping, discounts and gifts Gift with purchase ✓Including selectable gifts ⊖Limited: Only automatic fixed gifts Buy More Save More quantity discounts ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Switch to subscription ✓Yes, with selectable delivery cadence ✓Yes, subscription upsells Express checkout ✓Yes: Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay, PayPal ✓Yes, express payments Discount code field ✓Yes ✓Yes Shipping protection and add-ons ✓Integrations and add-on widgets ⊖Limited: Native only, no integrations Two-column desktop layout ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Schedule carts for promotions and flash sales ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Cart tabs layout ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell A/B testing ✓Yes ✓Yes App integrations ✓40+ ⊖Limited: ~14About 14, listed in Aftersell's help docs Custom CSS, JavaScript events, custom templates ✓Yes ✓Yes Cart analytics ✓Yes ✓Yes MaryRuth Organics raised AOV 27% with Smart Cart. OLLY lifted AOV 25.06% and subscription revenue 63% with Smart Cart and Dynamic Bundles.
-
Both run inside Shopify's native checkout on Shopify Plus. Rebuy chooses checkout offers with the same AI and rules as your cart.
Feature Rebuy Checkout Extensions Aftersell Checkout Requires Shopify Plus ✓Yes ✓Yes How products are chosen ✓Rebuy AI plus your own rules ⊖Limited: Manual rules or Shopify's recommender Upsells and cross-sells ✓Yes, single and multi-product offers ✓Yes, single and multi-product offers Text and images ✓Yes ✓Yes Trust badges ✓Yes ✓Yes Testimonials and reviews ✓Yes ✓Yes Tiered progress bar ✓Yes ✓Yes Subscriptions at checkout ✓Yes ✓Yes Discounts at checkout ✓Yes ✓Yes Shop Pay and accelerated checkout ✓Yes ✓Yes No-code editor ✓Yes, drag-and-drop ✓Yes, no-code designer Performance tracking ✓Yes ✓Yes, checkout dashboard -
Both offer one-click post-purchase upsells on every Shopify plan, with upsell and downsell paths, discounts, timers and subscription swaps. Rebuy's offers come from the same AI that runs the rest of your store.
Feature Rebuy Post-Purchase Offers Aftersell Post-Purchase One-click, no payment re-entry ✓Yes ✓Yes Available on all Shopify plans ✓Yes ✓Yes AI and custom offers ✓Yes, Rebuy AI plus your own rules ✓Yes, Smart Funnels or manual rules Multiple offers live at once ✓Yes, up to 40, each with its own targeting rules ✓Yes Multi-step upsell and downsell flows ✓Yes ✓Yes Discounting ✓Yes, percentage or fixed, with compare-at pricing ✓Yes Countdown timers ✓Yes ✓Yes Ratings and reviews ✓Yes ✓Yes Translations ✓Yes ✓Yes Fulfillment hold window ✓Yes ✓Yes Feals grew post-purchase revenue per visitor 300%, with offers converting at 21.58%. Momofuku reached a 16.25% post-purchase conversion rate. Polyvinyl saw 15% of shoppers take a mystery vinyl offer.
-
Both are free and show partner offers after checkout. Monetize needs no other Rebuy package.
Feature Rebuy Monetize Rokt Thanks (Aftersell) Cost ✓Free ✓Free Thank-you page ✓Yes ✓Yes Order status page ✓Yes ✓Yes Advertisers ✓Apple, Hilton, Disney+, Prime Video, Ocado, AG1, Revolut ✓Rokt Network Advertising quality control ✓Brand-safe network of premium, household-name advertisers ✓Partner pre-vetted for brand safety Customer data protection ✓Yes ✓Yes AI personalization ✓Yes, using an identity graph of 200M+ first-party profiles ✓Yes, using AI trained on billions of transactions Competing products kept off the page ✓Yes, automatically ✓Yes, by blocking competitors Setup ✓Live in minutes, no code ✓Live in minutes, no code -
Rebuy puts AI recommendations and bundles on every product page and the homepage. Aftersell offers manually selected upsells and bundles on product pages.
Feature Rebuy Aftersell Product page upsells and cross-sells ✓Yes, embedded on the page or as pop-ups ⊖Limited: Manually selected, up to 5 products. An on-page app block; the merchant picks up to 5 products per offer Homepage recommendations ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Frequently bought together and complete the look ✓Yes ⊖Limited: Manually selected bundles. Product page upsells offer a Buy It Together style bundle that the merchant sets up Trending, top sellers and recently viewed ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Mystery gifts and dynamic discounts ✓Yes ⊖Limited: Via pop-up Subscription upsell pop-ups and modals ✓Yes ✓Yes AI bundles on product and home pages ✓Yes, Dynamic Bundles with variant selectors and one-click add ⊖Limited: Manually selected product page bundles. Bundles with a single discount or a Buy X, Get Y offer, picked by the merchant rather than AI Build-your-own bundles ✓Yes, Bundle Builder: full-page, multi-step, up to 8 products, no new SKUs ⊖Limited: After purchase onlyBuild a Box, as a post-purchase offer Bundle analytics ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Widgets in emails, blog posts and landing pages ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell MOSH lifted AOV 19% with Merchandising Widgets. AU Vodka raised AOV 21.22% on Rebuy-assisted sales during BFCM with Dynamic Bundles.
-
Rebuy includes AI site search and collection merchandising. Neither is part of Aftersell's product lineup.
Feature Rebuy Aftersell AI-personalized site search ✓Yes, Smart Search, results in under 0.2 seconds ✕Not documented by Aftersell Add to cart and star ratings in search results ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Blog and page results (content search) ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Keyword redirects, promoted products, boost, demote or hide rules ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Search analytics ✓Yes, in real time ✕Not documented by Aftersell Collection pages with campaign scheduling ✓Yes, Smart Collections: layouts, filters, promo tiles, badges and analytics ✕Not documented by Aftersell Search API for headless and Hydrogen stores ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Still & Bloom raised AOV 30% with Smart Search. Cabau raised AOV 27%.
-
Both test offers and report revenue. Rebuy tests across the whole store, schedules tests ahead, and adds no-code promotions, campaigns and reorder pages.
Feature Rebuy Aftersell What you can A/B test ✓Recommendations, merchandising, search, content, widgets, cart, post-purchase and Monetize offers ⊖Limited: Cart, checkout and post-purchase Schedule tests ahead ✓Yes ✕Not documented by Aftersell Automatic winner selection ✓Yes ✓Yes, through Smart Funnels Revenue attribution By widget, flow, search and cart By offer and variant No-code promotions and campaigns ✓Smart Flows: multi-step journeys with conditional logic and real-time triggers ✕Not documented by Aftersell Buy X Get Y, flash sales and VIP campaigns ✓Smart Flows ✕Not documented by Aftersell Reorder pages with prefilled carts ✓Reorder Landing Pages ✕Not documented by Aftersell One brand drove over $30,000 in incremental revenue from a single Smart Flow in under three hours.
-
Rebuy publishes 40+ integrations and a developer API; Aftersell's help docs list about 14 integrations and no general API. Both hold SOC 2 reports.
Feature Rebuy Aftersell App integrations ✓40+, including Klaviyo, Attentive, Recharge, Yotpo and more ⊖Limited: ~14About 14, listed in Aftersell's help docs Developer API ✓Yes ✕No general developer API, per its help docs Headless storefronts ✓APIs for any headless storefront, plus a Hydrogen SDK. REST APIs for recommendations, Data Sources and Smart Search work with any headless storefront. The Hydrogen SDK and the framework-agnostic core SDK are in beta ⊖Limited: Checkout and post-purchase. Checkout widgets run inside Shopify's checkout on any storefront; custom checkouts add post-purchase offers through the Rokt Web SDK Custom CSS, JavaScript and templates ✓Yes ✓Yes Security ✓SOC 2 Type II, SOC 3, GDPR, CCPA, annual penetration tests ✓SOC 2 report on request; Rokt holds SOC 2 Type II Support ✓24/7 help center, live support every weekday, private Slack for enterprise, activation team ✓Onboarding support and account management for high-volume brands
Rebuy vs Aftersell: frequently asked questions
-
The main difference is scope. Rebuy is a Shopify personalization platform that runs one AI engine across the homepage, product pages, search, collections, bundles, cart, checkout, post-purchase and the thank-you page. Aftersell focuses on upsells in the cart, at checkout and after purchase.
-
Yes, for Shopify brands that want personalization across the whole store, not only around checkout. Rebuy covers the cart, checkout, post-purchase and thank-you page, and adds site search, smart collections, bundles and recommendation widgets for any page.
-
Both price by monthly Shopify orders. Up to 500 orders a month, Rebuy's cart, post-purchase and combined packages each cost less than Aftersell's matching plans. Rebuy also takes up to 30% off when you bundle packages and another 10% for annual billing.
-
Yes. Rebuy Post-Purchase Offers add one-click upsells after payment with no card re-entry. Offers use Rebuy AI or your own rules, with multi-step upsell and downsell flows and A/B testing.
-
Rebuy Monetize. It is free, shows offers from brands like Prime Video and HelloFresh on your thank-you and order status pages, and pays stores in the US, Canada and the UK.
-
Yes. Monetize is available to UK stores, which earn an average of £0.10 to £0.15 per order, about £15,000 for every 100,000 orders. It is also available in the US and Canada. Offers vary by location.
-
No. Monetize is free and works without any other Rebuy package. Stores selling adult products, weapons or CBD are not eligible.
-
Only for checkout upsells, on both platforms. Rebuy marks only Checkout Extensions as Shopify Plus only, and Monetize works on every Shopify plan.
-
Site search and collection pages are not part of Aftersell's product lineup. Rebuy offers both, with Smart Search and Smart Collections, powered by the same AI as your cart and post-purchase offers.
-
Rebuy has a full Bundle Builder, and Aftersell's is limited to after purchase.
- Rebuy Bundle Builder: shoppers build their own bundle before they buy, on a full-page, multi-step builder with up to 8 products and no new SKUs.
- Aftersell Build a Box: runs as a post-purchase offer, after the shopper has paid.
Rebuy also adds AI-powered Dynamic Bundles to product and home pages.
-
Yes. Rebuy offers APIs, including a Smart Search API for headless and Hydrogen stores, plus custom templates and JavaScript events for Smart Cart. Aftersell's help docs say it does not provide a general developer API.
-
No. Smart Cart, Merchandising Widgets, bundles, Checkout Extensions and Post-Purchase Offers all launch from no-code editors, and Monetize takes about 10 minutes to turn on. Developers can go further with APIs, custom templates and JavaScript events when you want them.
-
Rebuy installs in minutes, and Monetize takes about 10 minutes to turn on. Book a demo and Rebuy's team will map your Aftersell setup to Rebuy and help you launch.
- Map what earns today. List your top cart offers, checkout offers and post-purchase funnels.
- Rebuild them in Rebuy. Cart widgets move to Smart Cart, checkout offers to Checkout Extensions, funnels to Post-Purchase Offers, and Rokt Thanks to Rebuy Monetize.
- Remove Aftersell's app blocks. Take them off your checkout, thank-you and order status pages. Left in place, they can conflict with Rebuy Monetize.
- Measure against your baseline. Compare AOV and post-purchase revenue with your Aftersell numbers during your 14-day trial.
-
When you switch, remove Aftersell's app blocks from your checkout, thank-you and order status pages. Other app blocks left in place can conflict with Rebuy Monetize and lower its performance.
See what Rebuy would do on your store
Get a walkthrough built around your products, your order volume and your current Aftersell setup.
How we built this comparison. We compared Rebuy and Aftersell using each company's public product pages, pricing pages and help docs as of November 5, 2026. We review this page every quarter.